National Research Council proposes priorities for research on gun-related violence in US

National Academy of SciencesJun 7 2013

A new report from the Institute of Medicine and National Research Council proposes priorities for a research agenda to improve understanding of the public health aspects of gun-related violence, including its causes, health burden, and possible interventions. The committee that wrote the report said significant progress can be achieved in three to five years through a research program that addresses five high-priority areas: the characteristics of gun violence, risk and protective factors, prevention and other interventions, gun safety technology, and the influence of video games and other media.

The report stems from executive orders issued by President Obama in January 2013 directing federal agencies to improve knowledge of the causes of firearm violence, interventions that might prevent it, and strategies to minimize its public health burden. One of these executive orders charged the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention with identifying the most pressing firearm-related violence research needs. In turn, CDC and the CDC Foundation asked IOM and the Research Council to recommend a research agenda on the public health aspects of firearm-related violence. The committee determined potential research topics by surveying previous relevant research, receiving public input, and using expert judgment. It was not asked to consider the amount and sources of funding required to carry out the research agenda and did not specify the methodologies that should be used to address the topics.

"The complexity and frequency of gun-related violence combined with its impact on the health and safety of the nation's residents make it a topic of considerable public health importance," said Alan Leshner, chair of the study committee and CEO of the American Association for the Advancement of Science. "Therefore, when developing its agenda, the committee took a public health approach that focused on gun violence problems associated with significant levels of injuries and fatalities. Although this research agenda is an initial, not all-encompassing set of questions, it could help better define the causes and prevention of firearm violence in order to develop effective policies to reduce its occurrence and impact in the U.S. Similar approaches to public health problems have produced successes in lowering tobacco use, accidental poisoning, and motor vehicle fatalities."

The committee said this public health research agenda should be integrated with research conducted from criminal justice and other perspectives to provide a much fuller knowledge base, as no single agency or research strategy could provide all the answers. For the five research areas, the committee identified the following key research topics:

• Characteristics of gun violence
• Characterize the scope of and motivations for gun acquisition, ownership, and use and how they are distributed across subpopulations.
• Characterize differences in nonfatal and fatal gun use across the U.S.
• Risk and protective factors
• Identify factors associated with youth having access to, possessing, and carrying guns.
• Evaluate the potential risks and benefits of having a firearm in the home under a variety of circumstances and settings.
• Improve understanding of risk factors that influence the probability of firearm violence in specific high-risk physical locations.
• Firearm violence prevention and other interventions
• Improve understanding of whether interventions intended to diminish the illegal carrying of firearms reduce firearm violence
• Improve understanding of whether reducing criminal access to legally purchased guns reduces firearm violence.
• Improve understanding of the effectiveness of actions directed at preventing access to firearms by violence-prone individuals.
• Determine the degree to which various childhood education or prevention programs reduce firearm violence in childhood and later in life.
• Explore whether programs to alter physical environments in high-crime areas decrease firearm violence.
• Gun safety technology
• Identify the effects of different technological approaches to reduce firearm-related injury and death.
• Examine past consumer experiences with accepting safety technologies to inform the development and uptake of new gun safety technologies.
• Explore individual state and international policy approaches to gun safety technology for applicability to the United States as a whole.
• Influence of video games and other media
• Examine the relationship between exposure to media violence and real-life violence.