Key predictors for combination of alcohol use disorder and depression uncovered

Reviewed by Kate Anderton, B.Sc. (Editor)Jan 28 2020

For people with psychiatric disorders, comorbidity — or the presence of two or more disorders in a single patient — is quite common. One of the most common comorbidities is alcohol use disorder and major depressive disorder. In fact, people with alcohol use dependence are almost four times more likely to also have a major depressive disorder.

Studies have already shown those patients tend to experience worse outcomes and higher rates of relapse after treatment, but a new study led by Michigan State University researchers may have uncovered key predictors for the combination of these disorders, information that could aid in both prevention and treatment.

This was part of a larger study looking at how people function in adult inpatient substance use facilities. We were interested if we could find potential predictors of comorbidity. We wanted to know if there were characteristics that we could identify at intake that would help tell us who’s at risk for comorbidity.”

Julia Felton, assistant professor in the College of Human Medicine, Division of Public Health and co-author on the study

The study, published in the International Journal of Mental Health and Addiction, specifically examined distress tolerance, or how well people tolerate stressful situations, and delay discounting, a type of impulsivity that causes people to choose immediate rewards over delayed, but more valuable, rewards. The study looked into the roles distress tolerance and delay discounting play in the comorbidity of alcohol use disorders and major depressive disorders.

“Delay discounting has been associated with many poor health outcomes, but it’s never been looked at in the context of distress tolerance,” Felton said. “That’s what we set out to do in this study.”

For the study, the scientists recruited 79 people (who were also part of a larger study on risk-taking and substance use) in a low-income adult inpatient substance use facility in Washington, D.C., within one week of entering treatment.

The majority of participants were male, low-income and identified as Black/African American; 77% reported being diagnosed with at least one substance use disorder; and 64% met the criteria for at least one psychiatric disorder. The researchers conducted a series of tests and interviews to measure delay discounting, distress tolerance, and alcohol use and major depressive disorders.

At the end of the study, they found that high rates of delay discounting and low ability to tolerate stress not only increases the likelihood that a person would have one of the diseases but also increases the likelihood that a person would have both diseases. Specifically, the highest number of participants, 23%, reported having both alcohol use disorder and major depressive disorder. Only 22% reported having alcohol use disorder alone, and 15% reported having major depressive disorder alone.

“The bottom line is that people who were more impulsive — so have higher rates of delay discounting — but also who were less tolerant of the stress were more likely to have both alcohol use disorder and major depression separately. But also, they’re more likely to have the comorbid disorders,” Felton said.

Felton said the findings are important and can be helpful in identifying patients who are at-risk for those comorbid disorders, and helping successfully treat those patients, particularly in substance use treatment facilities.

“It’s really common in inpatient and outpatient samples, that if you have a substance use disorder, you oftentimes have a mental health disorder — specifically a mood disorder — alongside of it,” Felton said. “We hope to target these personality traits to see if we could prevent the onset of alcohol use disorders and major depression or treat it after it’s already onset.”

As for next steps, Felton hopes to further investigate intervention options that would target delay discounting and distress tolerance, as well as look into how those interventions can be adapted to inpatient substance use settings. And while she explained that the results of this study are “preliminary findings” that should be replicated, they open some exciting avenues for other types of treatments.