New technique can predict potential preterm birth with 73% accuracy in high-risk women

University of WarwickJul 30 2020

A new technique that can spot a potential preterm birth in asymptomatic high-risk women, with up to 73% accuracy months before delivery, has been developed by scientists at the University of Warwick.

Figure showing typical GC-IMS output to a vaginal swab. Red spots indicate individual chemicals and machine learning identifies which of these chemicals hold discriminatory information.

Utilizing cutting-edge volatile organic compound analysis technology, designed to characterize airborne chemicals, the scientists ‘trained’ the device using machine-learning techniques to identify the chemical vapor patterns from preterm birth using vaginal swabs taken during routine examinations.

Their technique is detailed in a paper for Scientific Reports and could lead to a cost-effective, non-invasive, point-of-care test that could form part of routine care for women identified as being at risk of delivering prematurely. This could enable healthcare staff to better support those women during pregnancy and birth and help to reduce the risks to their baby.

Preterm birth is the leading cause of death in children under five and at present there are few accurate tools to predict who is going to deliver preterm.

The researchers initially analysed volatile organic compounds (VOCs) present in the vagina for a condition called bacterial vaginosis, in which the bacteria of the vagina have become imbalanced. Previous research has shown that bacterial vaginosis in early pregnancy is associated with an increased risk in having a preterm birth, although treating bacterial vaginosis doesn’t decrease that risk.

The technology they used works by separating the vapor molecules by combining two techniques that first pre-separates molecules based on their reaction with a stationary phase coating (a gas-chromatograph), followed by measuring their mobility in a high-electric field (an Ion Mobility Spectrometer). Using machine learning techniques, the team ‘trained’ the technology to spot patterns of VOCs that were signs of bacterial vaginosis.

The researchers then analysed vaginal swabs taken from pregnant women attending a preterm prevention clinic as part of their routine care. These women either had prior histories of preterm births or a medical condition that makes it more likely that they would deliver preterm but had shown no other indications that they would deliver preterm and were considered asymptomatic.

Vaginal swabs were taken during the second and third trimesters of pregnancy and the outcome of all pregnancies followed up. The first test had an accuracy of 66% while the second, closer to the time of delivery, had an accuracy of 73%. The test results means that 7/10 women with a positive test went on to deliver preterm. 9/10 women with a negative test delivered after 37 weeks.

Lead author Dr Lauren Lacey of Warwick Medical School and an obstetrics and gynecology registrar at University Hospitals Coventry and Warwickshire NHS Trust said: “We’ve demonstrated that the technology has good diagnostic accuracy, and in the future it could form part of a care pathway to determine who would deliver preterm.

“Although the first test taken earlier in pregnancy is diagnostically less accurate, it could allow interventions to be put in place to reduce the risk of preterm delivery; for the test towards the end of pregnancy, high risk women can have interventions put in place to optimize the outcome for baby.

“There are a number of different factors that could cause a woman to go into preterm labor. Because of that, prediction is quite difficult. There are lots of things we can look at – the patient’s history, the examination, ultrasound scan, various other biomarkers that are used in clinical practice. No single test fits all.

“VOC technology is really interesting because it reflects both the microbiome and the host response, whereas other technologies look for a specific biomarker. It’s the beginning of looking at the association of VOCs with preterm delivery. We want to develop this and look at whether these patterns could be implemented into a care pathway.”

The next stage of research would see a small VOC analysis device stored at a hospital so samples could be analysed on site. The hope is that it could eventually be developed for use in a labor ward triage so tests can be administered and results obtained rapidly.

There is a strong interest around the world in the use of vapors emanating from biological waste for the diagnosis and monitoring of disease. These approaches can non-invasively measure the health of a person, detect an infection or warn of an impending medical need. For the need described in the paper, the technology can be miniaturized and be easily located in a maternity ward. The analysis only takes few minutes, the instrument needs no specialized services (just power) and is easy to use. We believe that the analysis of odors will become commonplace for this and many other diseases in the near future.”

Professor James Covington from the University of Warwick School of Engineering

The researchers behind this study are part of the newly established Center for Early Life, based at Warwick Medical School at the University of Warwick, which launches on 31 July. The new Center builds on the University’s existing expertise in early life research by aiming to pioneer research into the formative factors in our lives such as this latest research.

I am delighted that the new Center for Early Life will facilitate further interdisciplinary collaborations, to the benefits of my patients.”

Professor Siobhan Quenby, Co-Director of the new Center and Honorary Consultant at University Hospital Coventry and Warwickshire NHS Trust