Study underscores the economic, mental health impacts of COVID-19 on people hit by climate disasters

Reviewed by Emily Henderson, B.Sc.Sep 12 2022

When the Children's Environmental Health Initiative (CEHI) launched the Texas Flood Registry in April 2018, the goal was to develop a needs assessment focusing on health and housing impacts of the greater Houston area, which was still recovering less than one year after Hurricane Harvey's devastating landfall.

In 2019, Tropical Storm Imelda dealt another blow to the state, causing significant flooding and battering an already battered community -; an example of how climate change is causing intensified storms and climate-related events to happen more often.

Then came COVID-19.

Building on the existing registry, researchers at CEHI, with collaborators at Rice University and the Environmental Defense Fund, deployed new surveys to assess the economic and health impacts of the pandemic nationally, but with a special focus on those hit by back-to-back climate disasters. Two results stood out.

Respondents with the greatest economic and mental health impacts from Hurricane Harvey were respectively four times more likely to experience income loss during the pandemic and five times more likely to suffer severe anxiety because of the pandemic than respondents who were not severely impacted by the storm.

This study underscores the cumulative effect of economic stress and mental health impacts on an individual's well-being when exposed to a succession of multiple crises. To see a four- or five-fold increase in these statistical models is very concerning, and the time between events highlights the cumulating and enduring impacts of these stressors."

Marie Lynn Miranda, director of CEHI and professor, Department of Applied and Computational Mathematics and Statistics, University of Notre Dame

The Texas Flood Registry is the first of its kind to track short- and long-term health and housing impacts of hurricanes using online survey data.

For the study, the team analyzed survey data collected between April 2018 and October 2020 from individuals impacted by Hurricane Harvey and other major flooding events including Tropical Storm Imelda. The registry originally asked about experiences during and after each storm, including property or income loss, as well as feelings of distress related to Hurricane Harvey.

Surveys to determine the impact of COVID-19 were issued in April 2020 with similar questions. Results were pulled from a sample of approximately 3,000 respondents who completed both surveys.

Economic and mental health stress felt during Hurricane Harvey had a greater impact on how individuals fared during the pandemic than issues of property damage and flooding. Non-Hispanic Black respondents and Hispanic respondents were more than twice as likely to report having difficulty paying rent or bills during the pandemic compared to non-Hispanic white respondents, consistent with other studies showing those groups have been disproportionately affected by COVID-19.

Researchers at CEHI say the study could help inform recovery efforts, which tend to focus on the acute impacts of natural disasters like property damage but neglect long-term effects such as mental health.

The research could also help federal, state and local officials identify those communities at higher risk of emotional and economic stress during and after severe climate events, who could benefit from additional assistance or aid.

"Natural disasters are increasing in frequency and intensity due to climate change, and this research shows that repeated disaster exposure affects resilience," Miranda said. "The emotional and economic impacts of these events, especially for high-risk groups, are felt for years -; long after the storm itself has passed."