Study reveals poor access to cancer care appointments across languages

Michigan Medicine - University of MichiganJun 7 2024

Researchers at the University of Michigan are finding that many patients may be encountering significant barriers to cancer care, even from their first phone call to a clinic. 

Patients attempting to access cancer care must go through several different levels of communication, both before their initial appointment with a physician and throughout their treatment. 

Making those first calls to learn more about available cancer care services or to schedule an appointment at a clinic is an important step toward beginning their treatment journey.  

Racial and ethnic disparities have been observed in the outpatient visit rates for specialist care, including cancer care. However, we know very little about patients’ experiences at the critical step of attempting to access new clinic appointments for cancer care.”

Debbie Chen, M.D. 

Researchers set up simulated patient calls and studied whether each caller was able to access cancer care – that meant whether the caller was provided with a clinic appointment date or scheduling information. 

Using standardized scripts, the simulated patients spoke in one of three languages – English, Spanish, or Mandarin – and inquired about a new clinic appointment for colon, lung, or thyroid cancer care. 

The simulated patients called 479 clinic phone numbers, which were provided by the hospital general information staff at 143 hospitals in 12 states.  

Researchers found that access to new patient appointments for cancer care was poor for all simulated patient callers in the study – only 41.5% of the 985 total calls were successful. 

Even the simulated English-speaking patient caller encountered challenges and were successful in accessing cancer care in only 61% of calls. 

About one-quarter of the 985 calls ended early due to workflow barriers, which included calls going to a voicemail that did not provide adequate information, or being on hold for over half an hour.  

In addition, researchers found that access to new patient appointments for cancer care was worse for non-English speaking patients. 

The simulated Spanish- and Mandarin- speaking patient callers accessed cancer care in only 36% and 19% of the calls, respectively, far less than their English-speaking counterpart. 

Nearly 50% of the calls made in Spanish or Mandarin ended due to language barriers when simulated patient callers were hung up on in response to asking “Speak Spanish?” or “Speak Chinese?”, or disconnected when the automated message did not provide language-specific instructions but required input to continue. 

Even after getting connected to interpreter services, some callers were unable to receive further assistance.  

"Our study highlights existing barriers that patients may encounter when attempting to access a new clinic appointment for cancer care and illustrates how this access point functions as a gatekeeper to cancer care services, with many patient populations, including patients with limited English proficiency, unable to even get in the door to see a physician for their cancer care” Chen said. 

“Thus, interventions focused on mitigating these barriers are necessary to increase access to cancer care for all patients.”

This study was supported by the University of Michigan Rogel Cancer Center (Discovery Award to Dr Chen), National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases (grant No. T32DK007245 to Dr Chen), and National Cancer Institute (grant No. K08CA273047 to Dr Chen).