New study reveals growing disparities in preterm birth rates

New York UniversitySep 27 2024

Preterm births have increased by more than 10 percent over the past decade, with racial and socioeconomic disparities persisting over time, according to a new study analyzing more than five million births.

The study, published in the journal JAMA Network Open, also found that some factors that increase the risk for preterm birth-;such as diabetes, sexually transmitted infections, and mental health conditions-;became much more common over the past decade, while other factors that protect against preterm birth declined. 

"Our findings not only show that preterm births are on the rise, but provide clues as to why this may be the case," said Laura Jelliffe-Pawlowski, the study's lead author, an epidemiologist and professor at the NYU Rory Meyers College of Nursing and professor emeritus of epidemiology, biostatistics, and of global health sciences in the University of California San Francisco (UCSF) School of Medicine. "Understanding patterns of and factors related to preterm birth is important for informing clinical care and the development of public health programs to address this critical need."

Babies born preterm or prematurely-;before the 37th week of pregnancy-;are more likely to experience a range of short and longer-term problems, including a higher risk for illness, intellectual and emotional difficulty, and death. Certain factors are known to increase the risk of preterm birth, including mothers having high blood pressure, diabetes, an infection, or smoking. In addition, Black, Native American, and Hawaiian and Pacific Islander expectant mothers are at higher risk for preterm birth, which is thought to be driven by a long history of structural racism experienced by these groups.

To understand recent trends around preterm births, Jelliffe-Pawlowski and her colleagues looked at more than 5.4 million singleton births (not twins or other multiples) from 2011 to 2022 in the state of California. They examined how preterm birth rates changed over time and explored patterns in risk and protective factors within racial/ethnic and socioeconomic groups. Health insurance type was used as a proxy for socioeconomic status, comparing public insurance (MediCal, California's Medicaid program) with nonpublic insurance (including private insurance and coverage through the military and the Indian Health Service). 

A growing risk and "alarm bells"

The researchers found that preterm births increased by 10.6 percent over the decade studied, from 6.8 percent in 2011 to 7.5 percent in 2022-;echoing a report from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) released earlier this year that also found an increase in preterm birth across the nation from 2014 to 2022.

Rates of preterm birth grew across nearly all groups, but varied by racial/ethnic and socioeconomic group. The highest rates of preterm birth were among Black mothers with public insurance (11.3 percent), while the lowest rates were among white mothers who had nonpublic insurance (5.8 percent). Preterm birth rates decreased slightly over time among Black mothers with nonpublic insurance, from 9.1 percent in 2011 to 8.8 percent in 2022, but were still significantly higher than rates among white mothers. In contrast, preterm birth rates jumped from 6.4 percent to 9.5 percent among Native American mothers with nonpublic insurance.

We found stark differences in terms of what it looks like to be a Black or Native American pregnant person compared with a white individual who is of middle or higher income."

Laura Jelliffe-Pawlowski, study's lead author

Expanding on the CDC report's findings by looking at risk and protective factors over time, the researchers determined that several factors were linked to an increased risk for preterm birth, including diabetes, high blood pressure, previously having a preterm birth, having fewer than three prenatal care visits, and housing insecurity. Notably, the rates of preexisting diabetes, sexually transmitted infections, and mental health conditions more than doubled during the decade studied.

"These patterns and changes in risk factors should be setting off alarm bells," said Jelliffe-Pawlowski. 

Several factors were found to protect against preterm birth among low-income expectant mothers, including receiving prenatal care and participation in WIC, the supplemental nutrition program supporting women and children. Unfortunately, the researchers observed a decline in WIC participation across most low-income racial/ethnic groups over the period studied.

What can be done to improve birth outcomes

The researchers note that their findings underscore the need to improve pregnancy care and promote treatments that address risk factors associated with preterm birth-;which are often underutilized during pregnancy, especially among mothers of color.

"We need to do a better job of sharing information with pregnant people about risk factors for preterm birth and interventions that may be able to help them address this risk. Some providers report not wanting to scare or overwhelm pregnant people, but pregnant people tend to report wanting to have this information," said Jelliffe-Pawlowski. "For those who are at increased risk due to factors like hypertension or previous preterm birth, for example, providers should be having conversations about how taking low-dose aspirin might be helpful to them and their growing baby. This also extends to things like screening for sexually transmitted infections and offering mental health care in a non-judgmental, supportive way."

"There is also important work to be done to improve structural issues and respectful care in WIC to increase participation," added Jelliffe-Pawlowski.

Jelliffe-Pawlowski and her colleagues are also working to develop a digital platform called Hello Egg to help expectant mothers better understand their risk for preterm birth, identify interventions that may be helpful to them, and create a healthy pregnancy plan co-developed with prenatal providers. Jelliffe-Pawlowski and the team at the start-up, EGG Healthy Pregnancy, aim to conduct a large study to see if using the platform boosts a pregnant person's knowledge; a key outcome will be seeing if this information sharing leads to increases in the use of interventions and, ultimately, to a reduced risk of preterm birth and other adverse outcomes. 

The research was supported by the University of California, San Francisco California Preterm Birth Initiative. Additional study authors include Audrey Lyndon of NYU Meyers and collaborators from the University of California, San Francisco; University of California San Diego; Stanford University; UCLA Medical Center; California State University, Northridge; San Francisco State University; Indiana University Bloomington; University of Alabama at Birmingham; and the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign.