Food subsidies in Poland has led to a drastic drop in deaths from coronary heart disease

Jul 21 2005

Changes in government economic policy on food subsidies in Poland has led to a drastic drop in deaths from coronary heart disease, says a study in this week’s BMJ.

In 1991 the Polish government cut subsidies for saturated fats - i.e. from dairy and animal sources. Researchers examined how this affected diet in the general population, and whether there were any changes to death rates from heart disease.

The study found that by 2002, deaths from coronary heart disease had dropped by over a third in the 45-64 age group - a 38% drop for men and 42% for women.

Over a similar period (to 1999), people were consuming 7% less saturated fat, while consumption of polyunsaturated fats had risen by 57%.

The sharp drop in deaths cannot simply be explained by the effect of any polyunsaturated fat, say the authors, but is likely to be related to the type consumed. Rapeseed and to a lesser extent soya bean oil made up most of the rising numbers of polyunsaturated fats available in Poland in the 1990s - both of which contain omega 3 and omega 6 fatty acids, also thought to reduce heart problems.

The researchers also looked at changes in smoking trends and fruit consumption after 1991, to see if these could account for the drop in mortality rates.

They found that the fall in numbers of people smoking - which would also result in fewer deaths from heart disease - did not match the dramatic drop in death rates after 1991. And although consumption of imported fruit rose during the 1990s - from 2.8kg/year per person in 1990 to 10.4kg/year by 1999 - the increase was not enough to influence death rates by more than 1 or 2%.

These results concur with other studies which show that partly substituting polyunsaturated fats for saturated fats in the diet, while maintaining a low intake of trans fatty acids, can reduce deaths from heart disease.

An accompanying commentary notes that Poland and the Czech Republic are exceptions in the east/west European divide, bucking a thirty-year trend which has seen heart disease rates rising or stagnant in central and eastern states, while falling rapidly in the west.

Poland’s experience is largely down to better nutrition since political reform, say the authors. However, while this study looks at the results of economic policy, it underestimates Poland’s agricultural strategy which invested heavily in domestic produce. The researchers considered the effects of imported fruit consumption, but didn’t account for home grown fruit and vegetables in people’s diets, says the commentary, which may also protect the heart.

These improvements may be at risk with Poland’s recent entrance to the European Union, say the authors. The EU’s Common Agricultural Policy “places large scale agricultural production and economics above health”, failing to produce the range of foods the population needs, and subsidising animal fats, tobacco and alcohol production. Reform of the Policy is currently on Brussels agenda, but seems clouded by “political horse trading”, say the authors.

Contacts:
Paper: Professor Witold Zatonski, Cancer Epidemiology and Prevention Division Cancer Center, Institute of Oncology, Warsaw, Poland
Tel: +48 22 643 92 34
Email: [email protected]
or
Professor Walter Willett, Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts, USA
Email: [email protected]

Commentary: Professor Martin McKee, European Centre on Health of Societies in Transition, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, UK
Mob: +44 (0)7973 832 576
Email: [email protected]

Click here to view full paper and click here to view full commentary